It's So Real
What makes some stories precious, others memorable, and others forgettable? Why do we let stories become real for us? Let's look at some research and talk about some books to see if you can find some answers.
Erin Slegaitis-Smith
11/17/20264 min read


I just finished rereading John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men.
By the time I reached the final chapter, I knew what was coming. I felt the tragedy drawing near, and I’m not too proud to admit that I cried a little. My heart was breaking for Lennie and George as I weighed the gravity of their choices. I’m sure I’m not the only one who gets teary at the end of this book—and this kind of response isn’t unique to Of Mice and Men. It made me wonder why we become attached to certain characters and stories, and why others may not feel the same connection.
I first read the novel as required reading in tenth grade. It
affected me then, but not as deeply, and some of my classmates seemed unmoved by it. How can a story break one person’s heart and leave another untouched? How can fiction affect us as though it were part of our reality?
One way to think about this is through the idea of the
“willing suspension of disbelief”: a reader’s willingness to set aside, temporarily, the fact that a story is invented. This doesn’t mean being fooled. It means entering a story on its own terms. Researchers use the related term narrative transportation to describe becoming absorbed in a story through attention, imagination, and emotion (Wimmer et al., 2020). For me, this sense of transportation can make or break a reading experience. If I don’t feel immersed in a book, I might as well be reading a dictionary. I may learn something, but it will feel like a slog. I want to understand what helps readers feel drawn into a story—not only so I can choose books I’ll enjoy, but also so I can use what I learn in my own writing.
Researchers have explored several possible reasons. One is
that readers may try to understand what a character thinks, feels, and intends. Bal and Veltkamp (2013) describe this process as one way readers might take a character’s perspective and respond to the character’s experience. We don’t have to share a character’s circumstances to recognize something human in them. You may never have been a ranch hand responsible for someone like Lennie, but you may know frustration, duty, or exhaustion from caring for another person. Even if you’ve been a caretaker, you may never have faced the impossible decision George faces at the end of the novel. Bal and Veltkamp (2013) also discuss the idea that fiction can offer a relatively safe space for experiencing strong emotions. A reader can feel grief or fear for a character without facing the immediate real-world consequences of the events in the story. In that way, stories give us room to explore difficult feelings.
It’s one reason I started writing. As a child and young
teenager, I used stories to process the world around me. If I was scared, I could let a character be scared, and then let that character face the fear. If I was depressed, I could write a character who was depressed and give them a path back to happiness. Maybe then, I could find my own way forward, too. Readers can also use stories to explore complicated experiences. We can read Where the Red Fern Grows and reflect on loss, To Kill a Mockingbird and confront prejudice, or The Hobbit and consider what it means to give when we think we have little to offer.
Research on fiction and empathy is still developing, and its
findings are mixed. In two experiments, Bal and Veltkamp (2013) found that changes in readers’ self-reported empathy were related to how emotionally transported they felt into a story. A later meta-analysis found small overall effects of reading fiction on cognitive measures, with results varying by outcome and study design (Wimmer et al., 2024). Other experiments have not found that a story’s narrative perspective reliably changes readers’ social or moral cognition (Wimmer et al., 2020). So I wouldn’t say that fiction automatically creates empathy in every reader. My own interpretation is that stories may give us a chance to explore empathy we already have. They invite us to stay with discomfort long enough to consider another person’s experience. That may not happen for every reader or every book, but it’s one possibility I keep returning to.
The stories I write begin in darkness, because our world
can be dark. But just as I don’t want to remain in darkness in real life, I don’t want my stories to remain there either. In some ways, I’m still that child and teenager trying to find a thread of light. As an author, I want to help my characters find that thread—and, by extension, offer readers a glimpse of it too.
Perhaps hope becomes powerful because readers have felt
the weight of what a character is trying to escape. If George were more like Carlson, I don’t think his choice would stay with me after the book ends. What moved me is the painful contrast between care and apathy in a world that seems to encourage apathy. George’s decision is complicated, and I don’t see it as an easy moral lesson. I see a choice shaped by love, fear, and an unforgiving situation. This complexity drives how I create characters in my fiction and I’m grateful that I’m still learning, and that I have stories to share with others. This connection we have with stories is a blessing.
But, what do you think? Recall a book or character that has
stayed with you—one that moved you deeply or lingered in your heart. What drew you into that story? What made you give it room to stay with you, even years after you first read it? I hope reflecting on those questions leaves you with gratitude for what stories have helped you learn, as it has for me.
References
Bal, P. M., & Veltkamp, M. (2013). How does fiction reading influence empathy? An experimental investigation on the role of emotional transportation. PLOS ONE, 8(1), e55341. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0055341
Wimmer, L., Currie, G. P., Friend, S., Wittwer, J., & Ferguson, H. J. (2024). Cognitive effects and correlates of reading fiction: Two pre-registered multi-level meta-analyses. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 153(6), 1464–1488. https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0001583
Wimmer, L., Friend, S., Currie, G., & Ferguson, H. J. (2020). Reading fictional narratives to improve social and moral cognition: The influence of narrative perspective, transportation, and identification. Frontiers in Communication, 5, Article 611935. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcomm.2020.611935

© essauthor 2026